Best Protein Powders for a Healthy Gut
April 3, 2022
Rhya Pachin, RDN, LDN, CLT

In today's on-the-go, on-demand, fast-food style culture, clients often ask which protein powders they can supplement into their diet for meal replacement, post-workout fuel/recovery, and even to supplement less than ideal protein intake from daily nutrition.


Protein Powder: Not all Scoops are equal

If you've ever taken a stroll down the protein powder and supplement aisle at your local Whole Foods, you know that there are a plethora of different brands. Isolate. Whey. Rice. Pea. Hemp... subtypes of each. Different additives or nutrients in each of the different types... the list goes on!


If you haven't been paralyzed by the sheer overwhelm of the options, and are further wanting to learn about YOUR options of which protein powder, or powders, would be ideal for you, then this post is for you!


Selecting your Protein Powder

Consider your current diet

Personally, I like to ROTATE protein blends. I don't tolerate whey, so I stick to pea/rice, hemp, and collagen. Most of us who eat animal protein eat a diet higher in methionine, which whey offers more of as well, so again I like the 🌱 plant proteins 🌱 to balance out amino acids and then collagen to make up for what I'm not eating a lot of (organ meats or bone-in meats).


Quality over everything.

QUALITY is the toughest part, as with most food these days. It's hard to know what is tested, but most brands on Fullscript tend to be higher quality and come from companies with stricter testing standards.


Different Types of Protein Powders: A Breakdown

Before we dive into my ultimate favorites, let's dive into each of the different types of protein powders and compare/contrast each! Plus I'll share WHO would benefit from adding each to their nutrition plan.


(pssst: Save this image to Pinterest for easy reference)

Summary and My Favorite Protein Brands

In most cases, protein powder is a pay for what you get type of situation, so stick with pharmaceutical-grade brands like:

  • Designs for Health, Xymogen,
  • Biotics Research, and
  • Seeking Health.
  • Nutribiotic has a plain rice protein for an elimination-diet-friendly option with zero sweeteners or fillers.
  • If you tolerate whey, Nuethix also has a good product for muscle recovery and support.

My favorite collagen blends include:

  • Designs for Health,
  • Vital Proteins (peptides to dissolve in coffee, water, or tea) or
  • Biotics Hydrolyzed collagen -- for a protein snack that tastes like a milkshake 🙂


Still lost when it comes to selecting the best protein powder for you?

That's where I come in. I can help you figure out which protein powder will not only best benefit you, but also explain why - down to how your body metabolizes different nutrients (or doesn't)!

The turquoise water's edge on a sunny morning at the beach
By Rhya Pachin June 2, 2026
Functional nutritionist-approved summer travel wellness essentials for better digestion, hydration, energy, and recovery while traveling this season.
A corner of a house by a window filled with black mold spores
By Rhya Pachin May 7, 2026
Mold exposure may contribute to fatigue, brain fog, sinus issues, and other unexplained symptoms. Learn the signs, testing options, and what to do next.
A modern, clean white kitchen with 4 barstools at the counter.
By Rhya Pachin April 9, 2026
How your home environment impacts your health—from air and water to light and toxins—and simple ways to support your body through everyday changes.
A woman is with her hair up in a bun with a black tank top is facing away, lifting a barbell
By Rhya Pachin March 3, 2026
Learn how much protein you actually need, the best sources, and how it affects hormones, gut health, and weight — from a functional nutrition perspective.
A blood-draw vile rests on a sheet with markers listed out, and
By Rhya Pachin February 3, 2026
Confused by hormone testing? Learn which hormone labs matter most, what they tell us, and how they help uncover root causes behind common symptoms.

Recent Blog Posts

Share this post!

About the Author

Rhya Pachin is a licensed dietitian nutritionist who employs an "integrative" approach to support overall health rather than addressing just one symptom. As a certified LEAP therapist, she designs and supervises custom elimination diets. Her focus areas include gastrointestinal conditions like IBS and IBD, autoimmune diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis and Hashimoto's, persistent weight issues, food sensitivities, and chronic inflammatory conditions in both adults and children.

The turquoise water's edge on a sunny morning at the beach
By Rhya Pachin June 2, 2026
Functional nutritionist-approved summer travel wellness essentials for better digestion, hydration, energy, and recovery while traveling this season.
A corner of a house by a window filled with black mold spores
By Rhya Pachin May 7, 2026
Mold exposure may contribute to fatigue, brain fog, sinus issues, and other unexplained symptoms. Learn the signs, testing options, and what to do next.
A modern, clean white kitchen with 4 barstools at the counter.
By Rhya Pachin April 9, 2026
How your home environment impacts your health—from air and water to light and toxins—and simple ways to support your body through everyday changes.
Show More